I recently attended a few more screenings at Alamo Drafthouse, one from Sentai Filmworks, namely the rather strange, twisty Book of Bantorra and more recently, brand new from FUNimation Entertainment, the horror anime (with vampires), Shiki.
I like vampires in Anime quite alot. However, I will admit that horror is not really my "thing", I'm more of an action man, and my taste in Anime featuring vampires probably reflects that (Dance in the Vampire Bund, Hellsing, Trinity Blood, MoonPhase, not to mention the vampire character Evangeline in Negima!?), so it's quite possible that I just don't "get" horror. Some possible spoilers are going to follow so if you've not yet seen Shiki you'll probably want to skip the next section and go straight to my comments on Book of Bantorra.
So anyway, about Shiki...
Now, bear in mind, I'm only discussing the first four episodes, which is all I've seen, and because they were so underwhelming is probably all I'm going to see of this series, too.
This show suffers greatly from VERY SLOW pacing. Seriously. Episodes 1-3 are ALL backstory and set-up. There are no fangs until the very end of Episode 4. To my impatient, American mind, this is just bad story telling. The whole set-up for this series could've been condensed into 2 episodes tops. It did not need to drag out over 3, nearly 4 full episodes. What we have here in the beginning is more of a dry "medical drama" as a team of doctors in rural Japan (yes, even Japan, tiny as it is, apparently has its own version of B.F.E., namely the setting of this story) try to scientifically analyze a string of mysterious deaths caused either by an unknown disease or darker forces...? (hint: yeah, it's darker forces) This follows a long tradition of plague and disease being associated with vampires, from Braham Stoker's Dracula through the German Expressionist Nosferatu, etc.
I also understand that the Japanese take on horror is to creep their audiences out with eerie, creepy atmospheres and settings, or as a recent AWO podcast put it, beat their audiences over the head with it. Shiki most definitely takes this approach, and mabye it works for the original Japanese audiences, but it falls flat this side of the Pacific, I'm sad to say.
Some may say the long set-up is necessary, but I disagree. And I'm also not saying Japanese anime just isn't able to do horror right or do it justice, it can. You want to see an example of what I consider to be a highly successful horror anime that is genuinely creepy?
Look no further than Ghost Hound
To my mind, even from episode 1, Ghost Hound succeeds in spades, develops slowly, but piques and holds my interest from the very start to the final episode. Shiki fails in this, at least in episode 1-4. Maybe it gets better later on; some assert as much and say I should hold on and not miss episode 6. I dunno. If FUNimation screens a continuation of the next 4 episodes at Alamo Drafthouse, I may consider it, but I'm not in any hurry to buy a copy of Shiki nor am I eager to catch it on streaming...I've got a lot of other shows to watch and Shiki is pretty far down on my list of priorities and certainly isn't a "must see" for me.
Anyway, though the vampires are alluded to in Episode 3, no fangs get bared until the final scenes of Episode 4. There is also discussion of who tends to become a vampire after death, and some of the consensus in the fictional universe of Shiki are people who die with many regrets...sound familiar? It should, since this was also a thematic element of how the Shikabane got created in the series Shikabane Hime a.k.a. Corpse Princess, also from FUNimation. The Shikabane, if you recall, were ultraviolent zombies...reanimated corpses of dead people who refuse to die and persist in the world of the living through sheer force of will and blind rage or animosity, and can only be destroyed by the Shikabane Hime or Corpse Princesses, whose sole mission as powerful undead are to destroy all Shikabane and protect humankind from being preyed upon by them.
Again, Shikabane Hime is a fantastic series that has held my attention from episode 1 and continues to thrill me. I'm pretty far into it but not finished yet with it on Netflix streaming. But it's also definitely more of an "action" series than "horror", and once again, I fully admit that maybe I just don't "get" horror and that horror may simply not be for me.
One point I did consider is that perhaps Shiki is deliberately boring its audiences to death in the first four episodes so that we can more greatly empathize with the show's restless and bored teenage protagonists who are very moody, weltschmerzy, and eager to get the hell out of this po-dunk, backwater town. But I don't think the writers of this show or the producers of this anime adaptation are that genuinely clever; it's just an ironic truism and a byproduct one notes upon reflection.
Earlier, I happened to attend a screening of Sentai Filmwork's Book of Bantorra.
I was especially keen on attending because it was also reported that ADR director Chris Ayres would be in attendance, along with a gaggle of other cast members, including Chris's equally famous brother Greg, and Josh Grelle and Tiffany Grant, among others. Sadly not able to make it were Shelley Calene-Black and Luci Christian.
I have to admit, I really like it when Shelley Calene-Black plays really ballsy, tough women. She was fantastic as the lead in the older ADV Films series Noir and I'm currently enjoying her role as the no-nonsense ship captain in the bizarre sci-fi series Xam'd that I'm currently enjoying on Netflix streaming.
Also, Book of Bantorra has a set of protagonist characters who call themselves Armed Librarians, so I had to go check and see what was up with that.
Lemme just say that after the first four episodes, I can mainly say that Book of Bantorra is a very, very strange place indeed. It has bad guys facing down, at times, seemingly even WORSE guys. Very few characters, save Greg Ayres' character Volken, seem to occupy any particular moral high ground. Shelley Calene-Black voices the very busty, borderline psychotic Hamyuts Meseta (ハミュッツ=メセタ Hamyuttsu Meseta?), whom ADR director Chris Ayers in the Q&A afterward identified as one of the main characters of the show. Meseta is a particularly frightening character, one of those persons of whom you'd say, "I'm glad you're on OUR side", or "sure, she's a bloodthirsty, crazy b*tch, but she's OUR bloodthirsty, crazy b*tch".
Unlike Shiki, you definitely can't accuse Book of Bantorra of not being solidly action-packed; it certainly is. But it's definitely very weird and disorienting and even by the end of episode 4, it's not entirely clear what's going on; you may have a rough idea of whom the "good" and "bad" guys are, but everyone also seems to have their own private agendas and there are so many criss-crossed lines of fate and destiny at play.
There are several turns of phrase in English relating to the intersection of books and life; "My life is an open book", or "I can read you like a book", or the biblical "book of life", the Logos, or Word in the Christian religious tradition, etc. Book of Bantorra riffs on these ideas in a quasi-European looking setting and makes them concrete. People literally are transformed into "books", actually into magical stone tablets, after they die. These tablets are stored in perpetuity in the Library of Bantorra, watched over by the Armed Librarians, who serve, in effect, the role of guardian angels. One can pick up these magical tablets and review a person's whole life as they saw it. It plays out before your mind's eye like a movie. This is a theme also touched on in Season 1 of Black Butler, coincidentally. The Bantorra Library is opposed by the Shindeki Church, who seem, despite their religious moniker, to be highly Romantic, Nietzschean, hedonistic individualists who believe in living life to its fullest...they view themselves as the elect, the "Master Race" among the "Sheeple", so to speak, and they have a beef with the staid manner with which the Bantorra Library has been managing the affairs of this world and the next.
By episode 4 of Book of Bantorra, I was telling myself "yeah, this show is pretty weird; I don't think I'm going to buy it or bother watching it on streaming when it comes out."; The Q&A with the ADR Director Chris Ayres and cast was kind of fun, if brief. A few NEW cast members were introduced, some of whom this was their first Anime role ever, which was all kinda cool. Then it came time for the free drawings and lo and behold, I *won* a copy of Volume 1 of Book of Bantorra, namely the first 13 episodes. Well, the price was definitely right.
Again, wasn't a huge fan of the series, and I've got a lot of other shows in the queue to watch or finish watching before I finish Book of Bantorra. Chris Ayres was very enthusiastic about it and hyped the plot twists and turns yet to come. I remain skeptical but will give the rest of Book of Bantorra a fair hearing/viewing at a later, unspecified future date and I will update this blog with a full review of the first 13 episodes once I've had a chance to see them and think about them.
Anway, I'm looking forward to more Sentai and FUNimation screenings at Alamo Drafthouse, though I'm not all that excited by the June schedule for FUNimation. I am looking forward to the special Sentai screening on Monday, 11 June 2012, however. Until next time, Sayonara!
Recent Comments